Shadows vocals ... and other aspects of their appeal

[Fenderman]

I started getting into the Shadows when i was 13, that was back in 1987! All my mates were listening to new stuff such as Erasure, Duran Duran and Level 42. When i said i was listening to the Shadows they didn't know who that was!

[Iain Purdon]

I have a long held theory that whilst not necessarily their personal favourites EVERYONE actually likes Shads music and Hank's sound in particular - whatever they are playing as long as it's obviously them or him. The only reason a lot say they don't is simple fear of their peer groups!

Hmmmm. My wife isn't afraid of anybody and the only way I can con her into liking something played by any Shadows member is if it doesn't sound that way! Maybe she's the exception that proves your rule?

[Moderne]

I have a long held theory that whilst not necessarily their personal favourites EVERYONE actually likes Shads music and Hank's sound in particular - whatever they are playing as long as it's obviously them or him. The only reason a lot say they don't is simple fear of their peer groups!

Hmmmm. My wife isn't afraid of anybody and the only way I can con her into liking something played by any Shadows member is if it doesn't sound that way! Maybe she's the exception that proves your rule?

I'd go along with that, Iain. My experience is almost the complete opposite of Mike's; most people I've met over the past 40 years are falling over themselves to say how much they dislike The Shadows. Admitting to being a Shadows fan has always been a 'coming out of the closet' experience - like admitting to being a born-again Christian. I've said before that I've often wondered how The Shadows have had such a successful career and who the people were who went to their concerts as the majority of people I've met can't stand them!

[drakula63]

I'm a member of another forum - completely unrelated to music - and I tentatively mentioned the Shadows in their 'Lounge' type area.

The response was overwhelmingly positive and I think it's fair to say that all the comments in reply were to the effect that the Shads were bl**dy great! Not so positive about Cliff though. I think there are more fans out there than some people realise.

P.S. In reference to another post above... I went to see Duran Duran in 1987! It was an evening of hysterical screaming and crying and fainting and having to be attended to by the St. John's Ambulance crew. And that was just me!!!!

[MikeAB]

Rather proves my point - 'falling over themselves' no doubt to appear to be 'cool'! Why be so anti - methinks they protest too much.

Mind you I have spoken to many young people who have not heard of them and their 5 No 1's - that's a different thing really - and even that does not mean they would not subconciously like the music if they heard it I suppose, especially if they don't know who it is. Of course the 'young' don't like melodies/tunes much do they!!?

[Iain Purdon]

I'm not sure how but this thread has strayed well away from Shadows vocals!

[cockroach]

I'm not sure how but this thread has strayed well away from Shadows vocals!

Well, I started this thread, and I don't mind...I've been known to wander off topic meself!

anyway, it's all good interesting stuff!

[MartcasterJunior]

Of course the 'young' don't like melodies/tunes much do they!!?

An accusation levelled at 'the youth' since popular music began!

[MikeAB]

Yep - and we all said we wouldn't say it when we got old!!

Having said that, us baby boomers are probably more open minded about 'young' music than our parents - who didn't 'get' amplified guitars (even though they were tuned 'like real instruments'!) etc etc.

Just before my totally 'with-it' Mum passed at 88 I showed her my iPod and played her a lot of less well known songs that I thought she would surely like (eg Bonny Portmore by Loreena McKennitt) - and the look on her face was as though there was nothing musical there at all. I suppose when compared with Glenn Miller etc she may have had a point - but she wasn't prepared to even try to like them I thought - but she loved the Shads.

I heard a young teenager on the radio a while back being asked what he thought of the (now seriously dated) 'crooners' era - just before Elvis etc. He was played someone I can't recall and said something I thought was so sad, along these lines '' why do they have to sing the words - just say them'' i.e. 'rap' them.

We surely were the luckiest generation music wise I think - and for me the Shads started it all!

[Iain Purdon]

I'm not sure how but this thread has strayed well away from Shadows vocals!

Well, I started this thread, and I don't mind...I've been known to wander off topic meself!
anyway, it's all good interesting stuff!

Fair enough John. I've taken the liberty of retitling the thread so that the label continues to match the tin!